Division A: Season 1

Champion: Denver Broncos/ Winter 2002

Division B: Season 2

Champion: Oakland Raiders/Winter-Spring 2003

Division A: Season 3

Champion: Tampa Bay Buccaneers/Summer 2003

Division A: Season 4

Champion: St. Louis Rams/Fall 2003

Division A: Season 5

Champion: New England Patriots/Fall 2004

Division B: Season 6

Champion: Baltimore Ravens/Summer 2005

 Division B: Season 7

Champion: Dallas Cowboys/Summer 2005 (half-season)

 Division A: Season 8

Champion: Denver Broncos/Fall 2006 (Madden)

 Division C: Season 9

Champion: San Diego Chargers/Summer 2007 (Madden, 13 wk.)

 Division A: Season 10

Champion: "Philadelphia Flight"/Fall 2007 (All-Pro Football 2K8) 

 Division C: Season 11

Champion: "Pittsburgh Iron Men"/Spring 2008 (APFB 2K8, 8 wk.)